Showing posts with label why. Show all posts
Showing posts with label why. Show all posts

Sunday, July 7, 2013

Book of Mormon Intro -- Jews, Gentiles, Lamanites



 The intro to the Book of Mormon is part of what makes me curious about Joseph Smith's racial identity.  It appears that this book is supposed to be designed to bring harmony to a racially divided world, although the solution proposed is to make everyone conform to one worldview only.  I think most would agree to that.  

Clearly I haven't read the Book of Mormon in a while, and my reasons for reading previously were not really interest-driven.  But I, like the Eco Kosher Rabbe,  had the impression that Mormons were claiming some kind of kinship to the Jews.  And also claiming that Native Americans are the descendants of Jews.  So I looked up the introduction to the Book of Mormon, to look at it a little closer. 

This is the paragraph I am interested in:


Written to the Lamanites, who are a remnant of the house of Israel and also to Jew and Gentile—Written by way of commandment, and also by the spirit of prophecy and of revelation—Written and sealed up, and hid up unto the Lord, that they might not be destroyed—To come forth by the gift and power of God unto the interpretation thereof—Sealed by the hand of Moroni, and hid up unto the Lord, to come forth in due time by way of the Gentile—


So here, clearly it looks like Joseph Smith has what I think history has proven to be a friendly, if perhaps patronizing attitude towards both Jews and Native Americans.  And he's not really calling himself a Jew here or a "Lamanite".  He is obviously the Gentile, whose job it is to bring the book to the modern world.  It is interesting that he isn't referred to as  a Christian, though.  He is still using a Jewish moniker to describe his identity.

Saturday, June 29, 2013

A Gene of Religiosity

I was looking for something else this morning, but found this -- a post on New Order Mormon about a gene for religiosity.

http://forum.newordermormon.org/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=29806&view=next

Poster Hagoth says:


There is a study that links alcohol & nicotine use AND church attendance to genetics.

http://genepi.qimr.edu.au/contents/p/staff/CV235.pdf

There have been a lot of posts here wondering what exactly makes people want to go to church. Turns out the reason some people enjoy church and others abhor it might be genetic. AND the same gene makes you less likely to drink and smoke.

Friday, June 28, 2013

More Thoughts on Why I Should be Writing About This Topic

Gosh -- I abandoned this thing, because the genealogy thing frankly has a lot of bad associations for me.... racism, elitism, cliques... and my basic belief is that we are all related somehow, and just having Joseph Smith for a "Second Cousin Thirteen Times Removed" is not likely to make me the prophetess of the next generation.  And I'm not angling for that.  Although, maybe there's something to it for the shock value....

But I have been getting into arguments with my spouse, because we seem to have different understandings about what is and what isn't possible for our backgrounds.  I'm already flaunting my slightly less white-bread status to friends and casual acquaintances, now that I've found out I have a TINY sliver of African ancestry.  Why is it so important to me that people think about this as a possibility, not only for me (of usually Very Pale Face except when Confronted with Utah Sun), but also that others with Mormon heritage contemplate it about themselves?

Conversation with husband yesterday was about whether or not The Mormons of the African Lining (Like a Silver-Edged Cloud) could actually KNOW they were secretly African.  And thus bond and huddle together, finding strength in their numbers to FIGHT THE OPPRESSOR -- the Government who Knows about our One Drop.  (Which sounded cool to me...)

Or whether it was just some coincidental fact because it's just an Early American Thing.  If you have ancestors from this country that go way back, you may have  African too.  Wake Up!  Smell your coffee!  And Where it Came From, Ye of America.

Of course I think what steers away from cementing these ideas as firmly true is the sternly conservative nature of the Modern Mormon Majority.  As if that would mean you couldn't have African ancestry.  Sadly, we must still contemplate how a conservative might go about diversifying their genome, and it is not a pretty thought.....

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

CEU & You

So....getting started here is proving to be a little tricky.  I'm going to go at this journal style, and just sketch some different ideas out.  I have quite a few topics for discussion that I think will prove to be interesting.

The first thing -- one of the reasons I hit upon the name for "my mormon dna" is not because I believe in some cosmic, preexistence-determined genetic religious identity.   I grew up on genealogy, as most faithful LDS do.  Many hours were spent at the genealogy library, combing through microfiche for little tidbits of data about ancestry. At the time, I found this about as dull as the Book of Mormon, although for some reason my family and culture were in great earnest about it.  It seemed to mean so much to be able to find out who these ancestors were.  Yet the bulk of what we found, as far as I could see, was just names, dates and places.  I suppose it was left to me to fill in the inspirational bits about how lucky we were to be guided to the great state of Zion, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera.  It did not work that way, however.  Mostly I just felt like I was reading a phone book and waiting for someone to call me.

Fast forward a bit.  I became interested in science and biology in high school.  The strong hold on reality provided through this medium was comforting.  I think my interest was almost more cosmic, or mystical, however - in retrospect.  Mostly because I didn't follow the field and make it a profession.  I have always tended to view nature in a spiritual way, so any deeper understanding I could gain was that much more reassuring.  So I've always flirted with the biological sciences and genetic theories, as well as evolution.  I read Brian Syke's book -  seven daughters of eve- which even sounds like a melding of religion and science.

After having a child, genealogy suddenly became interesting again.  My daughter is beautiful, and also some might even say exotic looking.  Coming from such an anglophilic society, I wondered about her origins and mine, as well as those of her father.  We tend to think of human 'races' or ethnicities as neatly definable by the country of origin.  My exploration has proven that in so many ways, these definitions are limiting and the nomadic human likes to 'trespass' on geographic boundaries.  The challenge to science and genealogists now, I think, is to put all the pieces together from all different fields - anthropology, genetics, history, language, culture, etc.

What I can offer is insight from my own history and culture, as well as insight from new services available to consumers through genetic testing.  I used the testing services of 23andme, one of the leaders in DNA testing to find out more about my ancestral origins.  The field is nascent and there is still a lot they are learning and piecing together, I think.  Just because it is scientific, doesn't mean the answers are omnipotent or conclusive.  But being there for new discoveries is what is so exciting.

Anyway, again, I never before would have coined a term like "my mormon dna" before going through this testing process.  However, what I have had to accept is that the majority of my ancestors, as well as those of my husband, came from some similar background and mindset.  The challenge is to find out those commonalities.   (And, yes, there are still challenges -- to all those out there of a Mormon background who think all their genealogical trees are complete....)

There is an anthropological blog that is leading the way on these studies, led by a fellow named Dienekes -- in these studies, a mysterious ethnic population is used as a reference -- "CEU".  Come to find out, this stands for "Central European from Utah."  Mormonism segregated a group of people for a long enough time, that their genes are now iterative of each other -- there is a signature there in the genes, enough to say you may be related to a Mormon, if only tangentially - if your genes match with these "CEU" samples.